THE PLOT TO KILL THE PRESIDENT Themes & Symbols Explained

What the book is about

Themes

Opposition research as statecraft

The book traces a single file's journey: a conservative website's dirt-digging contract, passed to the Clinton campaign and DNC through Perkins Coie, outsourced to a British spy, then fed to the FBI, the State Department, and the press. What begins as paid campaign research gets treated as intelligence product, and the FBI builds a FISA warrant on it while knowing who paid for it. The line between a campaign's dirty tricks and the state's investigative power dissolves. Smith's point: when the government outsources its evidence to a political campaign, the investigation itself becomes a partisan weapon.

The Deep State and the 'soft coup'

Smith's epilogue names the scheme outright: Obama-era intelligence and law enforcement officials plotting to 'nullify the 2016 election' and 'remove Trump from office' by framing his campaign for colluding with Russia. The evidence he marshals is the Strzok-Page texts promising 'We'll stop it,' the 'insurance policy,' agents who never warned Flynn, and a wiretap built on an unverified dossier. Whether you read this as conspiracy or as accountability, the book insists the machinery of the state was turned against a sitting president by the people sworn to serve him.

Characters:Michael FlynnPeter StrzokDonald Trump

Institutional trust and its collapse

The FBI lies to the FISA court seventeen times by omission, its deputy director leaks and gets fired, its star agents text each other contempt for the candidate, and its special counsel cannot answer basic questions about his own report. Each institution Smith examines comes out diminished: the bureau, the Justice Department, the press that ran with the dossier, Congress. The plot failed to remove Trump, but it succeeded in something quieter and worse: convincing a large share of the country that the referees are players. That erosion, Smith argues, is the plot's real victory.

Characters:Donald Trump

The Blob fights back

For Smith, the deepest motive is not partisanship but the defense of a foreign policy consensus. Trump threatened the bipartisan establishment he calls the 'Blob,' and the Russia investigation was the establishment's counterstroke, an attempt to reassert the orthodoxy on Russia and America's role in the world. The dossier, the leaks, the special counsel: all instruments of a policy class protecting its monopoly. The book's bleakest suggestion is that the fight was never about what Trump did, but about who gets to decide what America does.

Characters:Donald Trump

Objects that carry meaning

Symbols

The dossier

A stack of unverified memos paid for by a political campaign, treated as gospel by the FBI and the press. Its journey from opposition research to FISA evidence mirrors the whole plot: rumor laundered into state power, then exposed as rumor.

The London pub

Where Steele confesses he is 'very worried' about Trump. The scene stands for the plot's origin: not an American courtroom but a foreign meeting of spies, lawyers, and analysts, the establishment conspiring offstage before the public ever hears of it.

Crossfire Hurricane

The code name itself suggests a storm aimed at a campaign. It stands for the moment private opposition research becomes a state investigation, the point where the plot stops being a story someone wrote and starts being one the government pursues.

The text messages

Strzok's 'We'll stop it' and the 'insurance policy' are the plot's confession, bias preserved in the FBI's own words. Their release marks the turn from Smith's narrative of suspicion to one of proof, the instant the investigators become the investigated.

Spoilers

The ending explained

The ending is deliberately anticlimactic: no one is convicted of the plot itself, and Durham's one trial ends in acquittal. Smith reads this not as vindication but as escape, the scheme succeeded in crippling a presidency and shredding public trust even though it failed to remove the man. The competing reading is obvious and worth holding: the same facts can be told as an intelligence community responding to genuine Russian interference, with sloppy tradecraft rather than conspiracy. What makes Smith's version land is the accumulation of small, documented failures, the FISA errors, the unwarned Flynn, the texts, rather than any single smoking gun. Whether that adds up to a 'plot' or to institutional arrogance is the question the book leaves you arguing about, which is arguably its real purpose.

Who is who

THE PLOT TO KILL THE PRESIDENT characters

Every character, where they appear and how they are connected.

All characters

Read the full THE PLOT TO KILL THE PRESIDENT summary

The full story act by act, every character and a quick quiz.

Open the summary