Malice of crows
In 60 seconds
Rhett Walker, a half-black, half-Comanche monster hunter, carries his dead friend Sam's bones across the Durango desert, hunting the necromancer he blames for Sam's death. The trail leads to a shadow-crow entity called the Malice, an ancient curse born from a massacre. With a shapeshifting girl named Cora and a one-armed gunslinger named Earl, Rhett learns the curse's origin and receives a sacred obsidian knife from Chief Red Owl. At a dead cottonwood on a salt flat, Rhett cuts out the Malice's beating heart, breaking the curse. He buries Sam's bones and rides west alone, finally at peace with who he is.
Before you start
Why it matters
This is a Weird Western that puts a mixed-race monster hunter at the center of a story about genocide's lingering wounds. The paranormal Wild West is gritty and well-realized, the monsters are genuinely gruesome, and the themes of self-worth, identity, and inherited guilt are handled with frankness rather than lecture. Readers who love dark fantasy with a moral spine, fans of weird westerns, and anyone drawn to stories where killing the monster means confronting what made it will find plenty here.
Spoilers ahead
The story
- 1
Act 1
Bones in a Sack
Rhett Walker rides through the Durango desert with a sack of bones behind his saddle. They belong to Sam Hennessy, the friend he believes a necromancer killed, and Rhett intends to bring him back. His only company is Ragdoll, an ugly paint mare he talks to constantly because she's the one creature that never leaves. In Burlesville, a girl named Cora stops him with a vision: 'You're looking for a man who ain't a man. He's got your friend's soul in a jar.' A talking coyote claiming to be a spirit guide complicates the trail, telling Rhett, 'You're chasing the wrong tail, Walker. The necromancer ain't your enemy. He's just a tool.' Rhett doesn't want to hear it. He wants someone to blame. In a cave hung with jars of preserved body parts, he finds the necromancer, a gaunt white man named Dr. Orin Hays, who admits he sold Sam's soul to something called the Malice. The Malice answers Rhett's rage in person: a massive crow of shadow and smoke speaking in a chorus of voices. 'You cannot kill what is already dead, little hunter. But you can join us.' Cora helps Rhett escape the cave, and on the run she reveals she can shapeshift into a crow. She explains the Malice is an ancient spirit of vengeance that feeds on pain.
- 2
Act 2
Gloomy Creek
Rhett and Cora reach Gloomy Creek and fall in with Earl, a one-armed gunslinger who lost his arm to a chupacabra and now hunts monsters for bounty. The town gives them the first real proof of what the Malice does: it possesses townsfolk and turns them into violent puppets. A possessed blacksmith attacks Rhett, screaming, 'The crows see you, Walker! The crows always see!' Cora gives Rhett the history no one wanted him to know. The Malice was born when a Comanche shaman cursed a group of settlers who massacred his village, binding their souls into a single entity of endless hunger. The trail leads to an abandoned mission, where a mural depicts that massacre, crows pecking at the eyes of the dead. Then the Malice strikes close. It possesses Earl and forces him to attack Rhett, who has to shoot his new ally in the leg to subdue him. Cora shifts into crow form and drives the Malice out of Earl's body.
- 3
Act 3
The Unmaking
That night Rhett dreams of Sam's ghost, and it is not the reunion he wanted. 'Don't bring me back, Rhett. I'm where I belong. But you got to stop the Malice before it eats the whole territory.' A band of Comanche warriors recognizes Rhett's heritage, and their leader, Chief Red Owl, names the truth plainly: 'The Malice is our shame. We made it. You must unmake it.' He gives Rhett a sacred obsidian knife used in the original curse, with instructions: 'Cut the heart of the Malice, and the crows will scatter.' The three ride to the Malice's lair, a dead cottonwood in the center of a salt flat, its branches crowded with hundreds of living crows watching in silence. The Malice emerges as a giant crow with human eyes and speaks with Sam's voice: 'You left me to die, Rhett. Now you'll join me.' Rhett's bullets pass straight through it. Cora shifts into a crow and attacks its eyes, buying Rhett the opening to climb the tree. Inside the hollow, he finds a beating human heart suspended in a web of shadows. He stabs it with the obsidian knife, and the Malice screams as its form unravels.
- 4
Act 4
Into the Dying Light
The curse breaks visibly. Crows fall from the sky, dead, across the salt flat. Cora collapses, human again, and whispers, 'It's done. The curse is broken.' Rhett buries Sam's bones under the dead cottonwood, saying, 'Rest now, brother. You earned it,' while Earl and Cora stand with him in silence. The three go their separate ways. Cora stays with the Comanche to learn more about her shapeshifting, telling Rhett, 'You gave me back my soul. Now I got to figure out what to do with it.' Earl heads east to hunt a wendigo, offering parting words: 'You ever need a one-armed fool with a grudge, you know where to find me.' Rhett rides out alone on Ragdoll, heading west. The final line: 'The desert stretched out before him, empty and full of promise, and Rhett Walker rode on, into the dying light.'
Who's who
Characters
- Rhett WalkerA half-black, half-Comanche monster hunter carrying his dead friend's bones, hoping to resurrect him. He learns to let Sam go and to unmake a curse his ancestors helped create.
- CoraA young girl with prophetic visions who can shapeshift into a crow. She becomes Rhett's ally, helps kill the Malice, and stays with the Comanche to learn her powers.
- EarlA one-armed gunslinger who lost his arm to a chupacabra and hunts monsters for bounty. The Malice possesses him and forces Rhett to shoot him in the leg; he survives and rides east after a wendigo.
- Dr. Orin HaysA gaunt white necromancer found in a cave of preserved body parts. He sold Sam's soul to the Malice, revealing himself as a tool rather than the true enemy.
- Chief Red OwlLeader of the Comanche warriors who claim the Malice as their people's shame. He gives Rhett the sacred obsidian knife needed to cut out the curse's heart.
- Sam HennessyRhett's dead friend, carried as bones and spoken to as a companion. His ghost asks Rhett to stop the Malice instead of bringing him back.
- RagdollRhett's loyal, ugly paint mare and his only companion on the trail. He talks to her constantly, and she carries him out of the story's final page.
What it's really about
Themes
Grief and letting go
Rhett spends the entire book hauling Sam's bones toward a resurrection Sam never asked for. The turning point comes in a dream, when Sam's ghost says, 'Don't bring me back, Rhett. I'm where I belong.' Rhett's quest to undo death is really a refusal to grieve, and the Malice feeds on exactly that kind of pain. Only after he stabs the curse's heart does he bury the bones and say, 'Rest now, brother. You earned it.' The book's point: you cannot resurrect what you lost, but you can lay it down with honor.
Inherited guilt and atonement
The Malice is not an alien evil; it was made when a Comanche shaman cursed settlers who massacred his village, binding their souls into one entity of endless hunger. Chief Red Owl owns it without excuse: 'The Malice is our shame. We made it. You must unmake it.' The abandoned mission's mural, crows pecking at the eyes of the dead, keeps the atrocity in view even as the heroes fight its monstrous result. The book argues that violence born of atrocity does not stay contained; it must be confronted and unmade by those connected to it.
Identity as both and neither
Rhett is half-black and half-Comanche, and the story treats that not as a problem to solve but as the lens through which he acts. The Comanche warriors recognize his heritage and hand him the cure for a curse his mother's people created. In the final chapter he rides west thinking about being both, and about how hunting monsters is the only thing that makes him feel whole. The book's point: identity is not a wound to heal but a set of hands to do the work only you can do.
Monsters as tools and masters
The coyote spirit warns Rhett early: 'You're chasing the wrong tail, Walker. The necromancer ain't your enemy. He's just a tool.' Dr. Orin Hays sold Sam's soul, but the Malice behind him possesses townsfolk, then Earl, turning people into violent puppets. The book keeps distinguishing the hand from the force that moves it. Its point: blame the small villain if you want a quick fight, but the real work is finding what animates the violence and cutting out its heart.
Found companions on a hard road
Rhett starts with only Ragdoll, an ugly paint mare he talks to because she's all he has. By the middle he has Cora, a vision-seeing shapeshifter, and Earl, a one-armed bounty hunter with a chupacabra grudge. Each pays a price: Earl takes a bullet in the leg from a friend, Cora spends her secret and nearly herself. In the end they split apart, each to their own road, with warmth instead of ceremony. The book's point: the people who ride beside you through monsters become family, even if only for a stretch of desert.
Look closer
Symbols
- The crows
- Sam's bones
- The obsidian knife
- The dead cottonwood on the salt flat
- Ragdoll
Spoilers
Ending explained
The ending refuses both triumph and tragedy. Rhett kills the Malice, but the victory costs him the quest that defined him: Sam's ghost told him not to resurrect his friend, and the burial under the cottonwood closes the errand that opened the book. What's left is a man who has unmade a curse born of a massacre and must now decide what a monster hunter is when the hunt is the only thing that makes him feel whole. Cora staying with the Comanche and Earl riding east strip Rhett down to Ragdoll and open desert, so the final image, riding into the dying light, reads two ways. It is an ending, the light literally dying, and a beginning, the desert 'full of promise.' The line lands because it holds both: a man at peace with being both black and Comanche, still riding toward whatever needs killing next.
For class or book club
Discussion questions
- 1.The Malice is born from a massacre and is called the Comanche's shame as well as the settlers' crime. Does the book fairly distribute guilt for the curse, or does it ask the victims' descendants to clean up violence done to them?
Worth remembering
Best lines
“You're looking for a man who ain't a man. He's got your friend's soul in a jar.”
“You cannot kill what is already dead, little hunter. But you can join us.”
“Don't bring me back, Rhett. I'm where I belong. But you got to stop the Malice before it eats the whole territory.”
“The desert stretched out before him, empty and full of promise, and Rhett Walker rode on, into the dying light.”
A fair critique
Where it falls short
The villain's mechanics can feel tidy: a curse with a single beating heart at a single dead tree makes the climax a matter of reaching the right place with the right knife. The Malice's possession of Earl is resolved quickly, and the townsfolk it puppeted in Gloomy Creek largely vanish from the plot once their purpose is served. Cora's shapeshifting and visions arrive conveniently when the plot needs an exit or an opening. Readers wanting deep exploration of the necromancer's trade or the mission's history will find both sketched rather than excavated. The prose favors momentum and imagery over interiority, which suits a chase but flattens quieter moments.
In one sentence
A monster hunter carrying his dead friend's bones must cut out the heart of a crow-shaped curse born from a massacre, and bury the friend he couldn't save.
Is it for you?
Who should read it
Readers who want their Westerns haunted, not just dusty, and who care about a mixed-race hero carrying grief in a sack behind his saddle. If you like monster hunting with real teeth, found-family gunslingers, and an ending that earns its peace, saddle up.
4 questions
Quick quiz: how well do you know Malice of crows?
0 of 4 answered
FAQ
Who wrote Malice of crows?
Malice of crows was written by Lila BowenI and first published in 2017.
What genre is Malice of crows?
Malice of crows is listed under Fantasy.
More Fantasy summariesHow many pages is Malice of crows?
Malice of crows is about 368 pages long (the median page count across its editions, per Open Library).
