Crime and Punishment

This is the novel that made the psychological crime story an art form: the murder happens early, and everything after is the inside of a guilty mind. Read it for Porfiry's interrogations, for Sonya, for the question it refuses to answer neatly—do ideals excuse atrocity? Anyone drawn to true crime, moral philosophy, or the roots of Dostoevsky's influence on literature will find it gripping.

1. 1

   Act 1

   The Theory and the Axe

   In July, in St Petersburg, Rodion Raskolnikov, a former law student, leaves his tiny garret room 'in the attic' of a five-storey house to visit Alyona Ivanovna, an old pawnbroker, on the pretext of pawning his father's silver watch. He observes her flat and agrees to return in a month. In a Haymarket tavern he meets Semyon Zakharovich Marmeladov, a drunken former titular councillor who tells him his story: he lost his government post, his wife Katerina Ivanovna is consumptive and starving, and his daughter Sonya from his first marriage has taken a yellow ticket and become a prostitute to feed the family. A man, Marmeladov insists, must 'have somewhere to go'. Raskolnikov receives a letter from his mother Pulkheria Alexandrovna: his sister Dunya was insulted and nearly ruined while working as a governess for the married Svidrigailov in the province of S—, and she is now marrying the wealthy lawyer Pyotr Petrovich Luzhin, who is coming to Petersburg; the letter says Dunya can marry Luzhin only if he takes no money and supports Raskolnikov at university. Raskolnikov overhears in the street that tomorrow evening, at exactly seven o'clock, Alyona Ivanovna will be alone, because her sister Lizaveta will be away; he takes this coincidence as a sign that his plan is fixed, and recalls that he first heard of the pawnbroker from Lizaveta, whom he met at a second-hand dealer's. Raskolnikov steals an axe from the caretaker's room in the house where the pawnbroker lives, goes up to the fourth floor, and kills Alyona Ivanovna with a blow of the axe blade to her skull. Lizaveta walks in on the scene; he kills her too. Raskolnikov ransoms only a few things — a small purse with earrings and trinkets, and items he stuffs into a box of trinkets and old rags — and never opens the strongbox with the money; he escapes unseen, hanging the axe back in the caretaker's room, and returns to his own house unnoticed.

2. 2

   Act 2

   Fever, and a Detective Who Knows

   Raskolnikov is summoned to the police station, where his landlady has filed a debt notice against him for unpaid rent; when he overhears the officers discussing the murder of the pawnbroker, he faints, arousing the suspicion of the young police clerk Zamyotov. Raskolnikov hides the stolen items in the courtyard of a house on V—sky Prospekt, stuffing them into a hole under a large stone, and does not even count the money in the purse; he then goes to Razumikhin, his former university friend, asks him for help in getting a job, and leaves abruptly. Raskolnikov falls into a fever and delirium for several days; he is nursed by Razumikhin, who has tracked him down, and who brings Nastasya, the landlady's servant, to look after him. Razumikhin and the doctor Zosimov discuss the murder in Raskolnikov's presence: a muzhik, Mikolka, has been detained on suspicion, and the old woman's clients are being interviewed; Raskolnikov listens nervously. When Luzhin arrives to introduce himself, Raskolnikov insults him and throws him out. At the Crystal Palace tavern, Raskolnikov taunts the clerk Zamyotov, telling him explicitly how he would have committed the murder if he had been the murderer, and saying 'I killed the old woman' in a low voice; Zamyotov is left uncertain whether he is joking. Raskolnikov returns to the pawnbroker's empty flat, asks to see the scene of the crime, and rings the bell of the old woman's room to relive the sensation; the workmen and caretakers suspect him and offer to take him to the police station. Raskolnikov sees Marmeladov run over by a carriage and insists that the police take him to his home on Kanavag; Marmeladov dies in Sonya's arms, asking her forgiveness, and Raskolnikov gives Katerina Ivanovna his last twenty-five roubles, saying it is a debt to his friend. After the funeral scene, Raskolnikov feels 'renewed' and goes to Razumikhin's; they return to his room together, where his mother and sister, just arrived from the provinces, are waiting for him; he cannot speak and collapses in a faint. Raskolnikov goes with Razumikhin to Porfiry Petrovich, the head of the Investigation Department, who is handling the murder case; Porfiry has just been talking with Zamyotov, and he adopts an ironic, insinuating tone, expressing great interest in Raskolnikov's article 'On Crime'. Porfiry asks Raskolnikov about his article 'On Crime', published in Periodical Discourse, in which Raskolnikov argues that 'extraordinary' men have the right to overstep the law for the good of mankind, citing Napoleon as an example; Raskolnikov defends the idea, saying the ordinary must respect the law and the extraordinary may 'step over' it. On his way home Raskolnikov is accosted by an unknown artisan who calls him 'murderer' and walks away; shaken, he returns to his room and falls asleep, dreaming again of the old woman, who laughs at him when he strikes her with the axe. Raskolnikov wakes to find Arkady Ivanovich Svidrigailov, Dunya's former employer, sitting in his room; Svidrigailov says he has come to Petersburg, that his wife Marfa Petrovna has died suddenly, and that he wants to meet Dunya again.

3. 3

   Act 3

   Confession to a Saint

   Svidrigailov tells Raskolnikov that he has ten thousand roubles for Dunya and offers to help her break with Luzhin; he mentions that his late wife left Dunya three thousand roubles in her will, and describes his depraved past, including his treatment of his serf girl and his wife's death. At the meeting in Razumikhin's lodgings, Luzhin is confronted about the slander in his letter; Dunya tells him she will not accept his terms, and when he insists on his conditions, she breaks off the engagement and orders him to leave. After Luzhin's departure, Dunya and her mother excitedly discuss their future, but Raskolnikov suddenly announces that he may be leaving them for good, tells Razumikhin to take care of them, and walks out. Raskolnikov visits Sonya in her room in the Kapernaumovs' house; she reads him the Gospel story of the raising of Lazarus from John, chapter 11; she reveals that Lizaveta was her friend, that Lizaveta sold goods to her, and that Lizaveta gave her a cross and an icon. Raskolnikov tells Sonya that he will come tomorrow and tell her who killed Lizaveta; he says to himself that he has come to 'test' her, and that Sonya and he are both 'step-children', people who have stepped over. At the police bureau, Porfiry resumes his psychological game, hinting that he has a 'little surprise' for Raskolnikov behind the partition; at that moment Mikolka, the painter, bursts in and confesses to the murders, and Porfiry, astonished, is forced to let Raskolnikov go. The old artisan who called Raskolnikov 'murderer' comes to his room, bows, and asks forgiveness: he was Porfiry's 'little surprise', a witness who had observed Raskolnikov's return to the scene of the crime and reported it to Porfiry. Luzhin arrives and accuses Sonya of stealing a hundred-ruble banknote from his room when she came to receive a donation; a hundred-ruble note is found in the pocket of her apron, and Katerina Ivanovna, in fury, turns on Sonya. Lebezyatnikov, Luzhin's former lodger, arrives and testifies that he saw Luzhin slip the hundred-ruble note into Sonya's pocket himself, thinking at first it was an act of charity; Raskolnikov explains Luzhin's motive — to avenge himself and reconcile with Dunya by discrediting Sonya. In Sonya's room, Raskolnikov confesses to her that he killed Alyona Ivanovna and her sister Lizaveta; he tries to explain his 'theory' of the extraordinary man. Sonya, horrified, tells him to go at once to the crossroads, bow down, kiss the earth, and confess aloud to the whole world. Sonya promises to go with Raskolnikov when he goes to confess, and she takes out Lizaveta's cypress-wood cross and puts it on him, saying they will go to suffer together; she keeps the other cross, the copper one, for herself. Katerina Ivanovna, driven out by the landlady, goes mad and takes the children into the streets of the Haymarket to make them dance and sing for money; she collapses, is carried to Sonya's room, and dies there, refusing a priest and saying there is no need. Svidrigailov appears at Sonya's door after Katerina Ivanovna's death and announces that he will pay for the funeral and place the three children in good orphanages; he reveals that he lives in the next room to Sonya and overheard Raskolnikov's entire confession.

4. 4

   Act 4

   The Crossroads and the Fever

   Porfiry Petrovich visits Raskolnikov in his room, apologises for his earlier treatment, and declares that he is convinced Raskolnikov is the murderer; he says he will arrest him soon but urges him to confess voluntarily, and mentions that Mikolka has gone off and a new suspect has appeared. Raskolnikov finds Svidrigailov at an inn (the 'Adrianople' tavern) and warns him to leave Dunya alone; Svidrigailov has arranged to meet Dunya by letter and threatens to go to the police with what he overheard. Dunya meets Svidrigailov in his room at the 'Adrianople'; he locks the door, reveals that he knows Raskolnikov's secret, and tries to force her to yield to him; when she refuses and threatens to shoot him, she fires a pistol but misses, and he lets her go. Svidrigailov, having decided to leave for America, gives away his remaining money — three thousand roubles to Sonya for the children, and money to the Marmeladov children and to a bride he rescues — and shoots himself in the head in front of a watchman named Achilles in the morning. Raskolnikov visits his mother, tells her he loves her, and asks her to remember him with tenderness; he then goes to Sonya, who tells him to bow down at the crossroads, kiss the earth, and confess. He kisses the earth at the Haymarket square and goes to the police station. At the police station, Raskolnikov learns that Svidrigailov has shot himself; he goes out into the courtyard, then returns and confesses to Ilya Petrovich, the assistant superintendent, saying 'It was I who killed the old woman and her sister Lizaveta with an axe'. Raskolnikov is tried and sentenced to eight years of penal servitude in Siberia; the sentence is relatively light because of his confession and his illness. Dunya marries Razumikhin, who plans to move to a Russian province, and Pulkheria Alexandrovna falls ill and dies. In Siberia, Raskolnikov is at first unrepentant and aloof from his fellow convicts, who dislike him; Sonya follows him to Siberia and works as a laundress and sews, visiting him; he falls ill with a long fever. Raskolnikov has a dream of a plague that makes people believe themselves the sole bearers of truth, causing universal destruction; after waking, he begins his gradual regeneration. One spring day he throws himself at Sonya's feet and weeps, and she realises he loves her. The novel ends with the New Testament under Raskolnikov's pillow, the same book Sonya had read to him about the raising of Lazarus, and the narrator's remark that this is the beginning of the story of the gradual renewal of a man.

• RRodion RaskolnikovImpoverished ex-law student who murders a pawnbroker to prove his theory that extraordinary men may step over the law. The theory survives the murder; he barely does—and only Sonya and Siberia bring him back.
• SSonyaMarmeladov's daughter, a prostitute with a yellow ticket who sustains her family and her faith in God. She reads Lazarus to the murderer, gives him Lizaveta's cross, and follows him to Siberia.
• PPorfiry PetrovichThe investigator who never accuses, only insinuates, certain from the start. He urges confession as mercy, and his certainty outlasts every alibi.
• SSvidrigailovDunya's depraved former employer, a man of appetites and sudden generosity, who overhears the confession and holds it as leverage. When Dunya refuses him, he gives away his money and shoots himself.
• DDunyaRaskolnikov's sister, ready to marry the calculating Luzhin to save her family, then breaking the engagement without flinching. She stares down Svidrigailov's pistol-point coercion and marries Razumikhin.
• RRazumikhinRaskolnikov's loyal, penniless university friend who nurses him through delirium and guards his mother and sister. Steady where Raskolnikov is feverish; he wins Dunya.
• LLuzhinThe wealthy lawyer who wants a poor wife grateful forever. Exposed twice—his letter's slander, his planted banknote—he is the theory's petty mirror: stepping over others for advantage.
• MMarmeladovThe drunken ex-official who narrates his own ruin in a tavern and dies under a carriage in his daughter's arms. His confession of needing 'somewhere to go' opens the novel's moral world.
• KKaterina IvanovnaMarmeladov's consumptive widow, proud and half-mad with hunger and humiliation. Driven out, she forces her children to dance for coins and dies refusing a priest.

The axe

The blunt instrument of a theory: borrowed from a caretaker, hung back after use, as if the idea could be returned too. It kills two women instead of one, showing that 'stepping over' cannot be controlled once begun. Its neatness in the plan and its horror in the act mirror the gap between Raskolnikov's arithmetic and reality.

The cross

Lizaveta's cypress cross, given by the woman he murdered and placed on him by Sonya with a promise to suffer together; she keeps the copper one. The victim's cross on the murderer's chest makes his penance literal: he carries what he took. Accepting it precedes his confession.

The New Testament under the pillow

The book Sonya read to him—the raising of Lazarus—ends beneath his pillow in Siberia, unread by him so far. It stands for a resurrection he has not yet earned, only begun. Its presence closes the novel on renewal as an unfinished process, not a verdict.

The yellow ticket

Sonya's prostitute registration, the document that turns a daughter into her family's breadwinner. It marks the poverty that pressures every choice in the novel, and makes her—the 'sinner'—the novel's moral center. Her fall is society's; her faith is her own.

The ending refuses both easy readings. Raskolnikov is not redeemed by punishment—eight years of servitude leave him proud and disliked by his fellow convicts—and not condemned, since the final pages belong to love and renewal. The plague dream is the key: a world where everyone believes themselves the sole bearer of truth destroys itself, which is his own theory writ large and universal. Only after dreaming his idea's logical end can he throw himself at Sonya's feet and weep. Some readers find the conversion abrupt, a pious epilogue bolted onto a psychological novel; others see it as the only honest outcome, since regeneration after such a crime could never be quick. The narrator's closing line—that this is only the beginning of a man's gradual renewal—lands because it withholds the ending we want: the book leaves him mid-resurrection, the Testament under his pillow still unread.

1. 1.Is Raskolnikov's crime refuted by argument, by suffering, or by Sonya's love—and does the novel itself ever answer his theory, or only outlive it?

Anyone who wants the founding text of the psychological crime novel, where the murder is the beginning, not the mystery. Ideal for readers of moral philosophy, true crime, or anyone who has ever argued themselves into something they knew was wrong.

FAQ